The Great Bag Debate: Which Fly Fishing Pack Reels in the Win?

Let’s be honest—fly fishing is one of those hobbies where gear addiction is real. We tell ourselves, "This is the last piece of equipment I need," and then—boom—another package at the door. One piece of gear that sparks endless debate (and maybe a few friendly stream-side arguments) is what type of bag or pack is best for fly fishing.

Do you go old-school with a vest, embrace modern minimalism with a chest pack, or sling your way to convenience? With countless options on the market, choosing the right one can be as tricky as tying a perfect size 22 midge on a windy day.

Don’t worry—we’ve got you covered. This isn’t some thinly veiled brand promotion; it's a straight-shooting look at each type of pack, who they work best for, and their pros and cons. No fluff, no nonsense—just honest advice (with a side of wit). 😎

Listen to the Podcast!

The Contenders: Types of Fly Fishing Packs

1. Fly Fishing Vests: Old-School Cool or Outdated Gear Garage?

You know that classic image of an angler standing in the river, vest loaded with every fly imaginable? That’s the fly fishing vest in all its glory. It's like having a tackle shop strapped to your chest.

Best for: Traditionalists who love having all the things at their fingertips.

✅ Pros:

• 🗂️ Pocket paradise: Plenty of compartments to organize your collection of flies, tippet spools, and that sandwich from two trips ago.
• 🏃‍♂️ Instant access: Everything’s right there—no spinning or flipping needed.
• 🧢 Timeless look: You’ll fit right in with seasoned anglers (and maybe snag some wisdom).

❌ Cons:

• 🥵 Hot and heavy: Not ideal when the sun’s blazing—hello, sweat city.
• 🎒 Poor weight distribution: Your shoulders will notice after a long day.
• 📦 Limited capacity: Good luck squeezing in a rain jacket or lunch.

🔥 Top Picks:

• Orvis PRO Vest: Built to last and pockets for days.
• Simms Freestone Vest: Comfortable and packed with features.

2. Chest Packs: Minimalist Marvel or Front-Loaded Frustration?

Chest packs are like the fanny packs of fly fishing—but cooler (kind of). They offer quick access without the bulk. Just don’t be surprised if you glance down and can’t see your feet.

Best for: Minimalist anglers who fish light and fast.

✅ Pros:

• 🎯 Quick front access: Perfect for swapping flies on the fly (pun totally intended).
• 🪶 Lightweight and compact: Your back will thank you after a full day on the water.
• 🧰 Organized compartments: No more rummaging for that elusive split shot.

❌ Cons:

• 👣 Blocks your view: Not ideal if you’re navigating tricky terrain.
• 🔥 Chest sauna: Can trap heat during warmer months.
• 🎒 Limited storage: Pack light or pack disappointment.

🔥 Top Picks:

• Umpqua Overlook ZS2 500: Spacious with modular add-ons.
• Fishpond Cross-Current Chest Pack: Comfortable with thoughtful features.

3. Sling Packs: The Hip Crossbody for Anglers

Sling packs are like the cool cousin at family gatherings—trendy, functional, and somehow makes everything look effortless. You swing it around for quick access, then swing it back out of the way. Smooth.

Best for: Anglers who want capacity without losing mobility.

✅ Pros:

• 🪢 Easy swing-around access: No pack removal gymnastics required.
• 🎛️ Solid capacity: Holds more gear than chest packs without feeling bulky.
• 🚶 Good weight distribution: Spreads load across your back and shoulder.

❌ Cons:

• 😣 Shoulder fatigue: Carrying it all day can wear on you.
• 🎯 Shifts during movement: Might migrate when hiking or casting.
• 🔄 Requires rotation: Not a big deal—unless you’ve got a trout on the line.

🔥 Top Picks:

• Patagonia Stealth Sling Pack: Water-resistant and thoughtfully designed.
• Simms Freestone Sling Pack: Ergonomic with plenty of storage options.

4. Hip (Waist) Packs: The Angler’s Utility Belt

Hip packs have evolved beyond glorified fanny packs (thank goodness). They’re perfect for anglers who want quick access without the shoulder strain. Just be mindful when wading deep—no one likes soggy gear.

Best for: Those prioritizing comfort and easy access.

✅ Pros:

• 💪 Shoulder relief: Keeps the weight off your upper body.
• 🛠️ Surprising capacity: Plenty of room for the essentials.
• 🦸 Freedom to cast: No pack getting in your way.

❌ Cons:

• 🌊 Gets wet easily: Not ideal for waist-deep wading unless waterproof.
• 🎢 Can sag: Needs proper adjustment to avoid bouncing around.
• 🔄 Access involves spinning: Awkward when balancing in a current.

🔥 Top Picks:

• Fishpond Thunderhead Submersible Lumbar Pack: Fully waterproof and bombproof.
• Orvis Waterproof Hip Pack: Sleek, sturdy, and thoughtfully designed.

5. Backpacks: Bring All the Things (But Should You?)

Sometimes you need all the gear. Backpacks let you haul jackets, lunch, extra layers—and that snack stash you swore you didn’t pack. Just remember: more capacity = more temptation to overpack.

Best for: Hikers heading to remote water or gear-heavy days.

✅ Pros:

• 🎒 Big capacity: Bring the rain jacket, lunch, and maybe a celebratory beverage.
• 🏔️ Balanced load: Perfect for long treks.
• 🔄 Versatile: Can double as a general hiking pack.

❌ Cons:

• 🚫 Hard to access quickly: Taking it off every time gets old.
• 🪨 Bulky: May snag on brush or restrict movement.
• 🎭 Overpacking temptation: Just because you can bring everything... doesn’t mean you should.

🔥 Top Picks:

• Fishpond Thunderhead Submersible Backpack: Waterproof and ready for adventure.
• Simms Dry Creek Z Backpack: Durable with solid organization.

❓ Most Asked Questions (Answered So You Don’t Have to Google Mid-Trip)

🥇 "Which pack is best for beginners?"

Go for a sling pack—it’s the perfect middle ground between storage and convenience.

🌧️ "Do I really need a waterproof pack?"

Fishing in rain-prone areas or wading deep? Yes. Nothing ruins a trip faster than soaked gear (and soggy sandwiches).

🏕️ "Can I just use a regular backpack?"

Sure, but you’ll miss out on features like rod holders and waterproof zippers. Fishing-specific packs are worth it.

🧳 "How do I choose the right size?"

Minimalists = chest packs.
Day trippers = sling or hip packs.
Backcountry explorers = backpack.

🐟 "Do these packs carry a net?"

Most modern packs do! Look for integrated net holsters (Patagonia’s Stealth Sling nails this).

🌊 "Hip pack or sling pack?"

Want weight off your shoulders? Hip pack.
Want easy access while moving? Sling pack.

Final Cast: Which Pack Should You Choose?

No one pack fits every angler (or body). It’s all about how you fish:

• 🕰️ Weekend warrior at local rivers? Chest or sling packs are perfect.
• 🏔️ Hiking to hidden gems? Backpack for the win.
• 🌊 Frequent deep-wader? Waterproof hip or sling pack.
• 🧢 Minimalist angler? Chest pack keeps things light.

 Whether you’re a gear junkie or a minimalist angler, the right pack makes every cast, hike, and fish land smoother. Choose wisely, pack smart, and—most importantly—get out there and fish!