Fishing Report: Tarryall Creek in Colorado September

Tarryall Creek, located in the South Platte River Basin near Fairplay, Colorado, offers a fantastic fly fishing experience with a mix of rainbow trout, brown trout, and even the occasional brook trout. The creek features diverse habitats, including fast-moving riffles, deep pools, and meandering meadow sections, providing varied opportunities for anglers of all skill levels.

Tarryall Creek Fly Fishing Report – November 4, 2024

As November settles in, Tarryall Creek offers anglers a serene and rewarding experience. The creek's clear waters meander through picturesque meadows and canyons, providing ideal conditions for fly fishing. Trout are becoming more selective, feeding primarily on midges and the occasional Blue-Winged Olive (BWO) hatch. Late mornings to early afternoons are prime times, as the sun warms the water, increasing fish activity.

Approach the creek with stealth, as the clear water and cautious trout require delicate presentations. Utilizing light tippets and small flies will enhance your chances of success. The peaceful environment, combined with the challenge of enticing these selective trout, makes for a fulfilling day on the water.

Conditions Summary

• Flow Rate: Approximately 15 CFS
• Water Temperature: 40-45°F
• Clarity: Clear
• Best Times: Late morning to early afternoon

River Flow Chart 

For real-time data on river conditions, visit the Colorado Division of Water Resources.

Tarryall Creek Hatch Chart

Top 3 Flies for the Week

• Dry Fly: Blue Wing Olive, Size 20 – Effective during midday hatches.
• Nymph: Black Beauty, Size 22 – Ideal for subsurface feeding trout.
• Streamer: Mini Leech, Size 10 – Useful in deeper pools during low-light conditions.

Tips for Fly Fishing on Tarryall Creek

• Seasonal Tip: With lower flows and clear water, stealth is crucial. Approach fishing spots cautiously and use lighter tippets (6X or 7X).

• Dry Fly: Focus on BWO hatches during late morning to early afternoon. Ensure a drag-free drift to entice surface-feeding trout.

• Nymphing: Utilize small midge patterns and target deeper runs and pools where trout are likely holding.

• Streamer Fishing: While less common in low flows, streamers can be effective in shaded areas or during overcast conditions. Use smaller patterns and retrieve slowly.

Access Points

Tarryall Reservoir Outlet

• Location: Just below Tarryall Reservoir, accessible from County Road 77 (Tarryall Road)
• Description: This is one of the most popular access points for anglers. The water here is tailwater, meaning it's fed from the bottom of Tarryall Reservoir, which keeps it cool and productive throughout the year. The section below the reservoir outlet is characterized by riffles and deep pools, which are excellent for both nymphing and dry fly fishing.
• Access Tips: Park near the Tarryall Reservoir parking area. Make sure to check local fishing regulations, as some sections may have special rules or restrictions.

Tarryall Road (County Road 77) Pull-Offs

• Location: Along County Road 77 between Tarryall Reservoir and Jefferson, CO
• Description: Multiple pull-offs and parking spots along County Road 77 provide access to various sections of Tarryall Creek. This stretch includes a mix of riffles, runs, and deep pools, ideal for dry fly fishing and nymphing. The creek meanders through willows and open meadows, providing a variety of fishing environments.
• Access Tips: Look for safe pull-offs and parking areas along County Road 77. Be mindful of private property signs and make sure to respect the boundaries. This road follows the creek closely, so it offers many convenient access points for a day of fishing.

Tarryall State Wildlife Area

• Location: South of Tarryall Reservoir along County Road 77
• Description: This state wildlife area offers public access to Tarryall Creek. It features several miles of fishable water with diverse habitats, including faster riffles and slow-moving bends. The wildlife area is well-maintained and offers a more secluded fishing experience compared to areas closer to the reservoir.
• Access Tips: There is designated parking at the wildlife area entrance. From here, trails lead directly to the creek. It’s a great spot for anglers looking for a quieter section to fish. Remember to carry a valid Colorado fishing license and adhere to wildlife area rules.

Tarryall Land and Cattle Ranch (Private Access)

• Location: Near Jefferson, CO
• Description: This private ranch offers exclusive fly fishing access to a prime section of Tarryall Creek. The ranch provides a unique opportunity to fish in a managed environment with less fishing pressure. The creek here flows through a mix of canyon sections, wetlands, and meadow areas, offering a variety of fishing conditions and habitats.
• Access Tips: Access is by reservation only, and anglers must book their trip in advance through the Tarryall Land and Cattle Ranch website. This private section provides a more controlled and guided experience, ideal for those looking for a premium fishing outing​

Jefferson Lake Road (Forest Service Road 129)

• Location: Off County Road 77 near the town of Jefferson, CO
• Description: This access point is near the upper reaches of Tarryall Creek, closer to its headwaters. The water is narrower and more technical, with a mix of small pools and pocket water ideal for dry fly fishing. The less frequented area offers a more remote and peaceful fishing experience.
• Access Tips: Drive along Jefferson Lake Road (FSR 129) and look for pull-offs where you can park and walk down to the creek. Be prepared for rugged terrain and be mindful of forest service regulations regarding vehicle access and parking.

Local Regulations and Notes on Landowner Rights

Ensure you have a valid Colorado fishing license and adhere to all state regulations. While Tarryall Creek has public access points, much of the land along the creek is private. Always respect private property boundaries and obtain permission if necessary. Practice catch and release to help maintain the fishery for future generations.