Fishing Report: South Platte River Above Spinney Mountain Reservoir 10.28.2024

The Middle Fork of the South Platte River, located below Montgomery Reservoir in Colorado, is a prime destination for fly fishing enthusiasts. This section of the river is known for its scenic beauty, diverse fish species, and a variety of fishing spots ranging from serene meadows to rocky, challenging terrains. The river flows through several state wildlife areas, making it accessible and popular for both novice and experienced anglers.

October Fishing Report: South Platte River Above Spinney Mountain Reservoir

Current River Conditions

The Middle Fork of the South Platte is a rewarding, scenic option this fall, with clear flows around 15 CFS and a water temperature ideal for trout activity, particularly brown and brook trout. The river’s small, technical waters above Montgomery Reservoir offer solitude and require precision casting, as trout are spread across riffles, undercut banks, and deeper pools. For those willing to take on the challenging conditions, the Middle Fork provides a high-alpine escape with stunning fall foliage against the mountain backdrop.

Current Hatches and Fly Recommendations

• Midges and Blue Wing Olives (BWOs) are the primary hatches right now, especially productive in the morning and early afternoon.
  • Recommended patterns include Black Beauty (#20-22), Zebra Midge (#20-22), and RS2s (#18-22).
• For nymphing, Pheasant Tail Nymphs and small Scuds (#16-20) can bring consistent action in the slower sections of the river, especially along undercut banks where trout lie.

Conditions Summary

• Flow Rate: 15 CFS
• Water Temperature: Cool, optimal for trout feeding
• Clarity: Clear and low, offering visibility but requiring stealth
• Best Times: Morning to early afternoon

The Middle Fork’s calm, technical waters, set in a quiet valley with expansive views, make for a rewarding experience for those seeking a peaceful yet challenging day on the water.

River Flow Chart

source: Colorado Divison of Resources Station Flow Report

Hatches & Recommended Flies

Dry Flies

• Blue-Winged Olive (BWO) Patterns
  Patterns: Parachute Adams, Sparkle Dun, Comparadun BWO
  Sizes: #18-22
  When to Use: BWOs hatch consistently, especially during cooler, overcast afternoons. These flies are effective in slow-moving pools and seams where trout are rising to feed on emergers and duns.

• Caddisfly Patterns
  Patterns: Elk Hair Caddis, Goddard Caddis, X-Caddis
  Sizes: #14-18
  When to Use: Caddisflies are active in the evenings, making these patterns ideal for fishing just before dusk. Present these flies in riffles and along the banks where caddis are likely to be hatching.

• Terrestrial Patterns (Hoppers, Beetles, Ants)
  Patterns: Chubby Chernobyl, Amy’s Ant, Foam Beetle
  Sizes: #10-16
  When to Use: Terrestrial patterns are especially effective during the summer and early fall when grasshoppers, beetles, and ants are abundant. Fish these flies close to the banks and in meadow sections where trout are opportunistically feeding on terrestrials​

• Trico Patterns
  Patterns: Trico Spinner, CDC Trico Dun
  Sizes: #20-24
  When to Use: Trico hatches occur in the early morning, making these flies a good choice for targeting rising trout in the slow-moving water of the meadow sections.

Nymphs

• Pheasant Tail Nymph
  Sizes: #16-20
  When to Use: A versatile nymph pattern that imitates a variety of aquatic insects. It’s effective year-round and can be used in both riffles and pools, especially when there is no visible surface activity.

• Copper John
  Sizes: #14-18
  When to Use: The Copper John is effective in faster-moving water where getting the fly down quickly is crucial. This pattern is particularly good for targeting trout in deeper runs and riffles.

• RS2
  Sizes: #18-22
  When to Use: The RS2 is a great emerger pattern for BWO and PMD hatches. It’s best fished just below the surface, either as a dropper under a dry fly or as part of a two-fly nymph rig.

• Zebra Midge
  Sizes: #18-22
  When to Use: Zebra Midges are effective year-round, especially in colder months or during non-hatch periods. They are best fished in slower runs and pools where trout are feeding near the bottom.

Streamers

• Woolly Bugger
  Sizes: #6-10
  When to Use: Streamers like Woolly Buggers are effective for targeting larger trout, particularly in deeper pools and around structure. They are best fished in low-light conditions or when the water is slightly off-color.

• Duracell
  Sizes: #16-18
  When to Use: This small, beadhead streamer pattern is perfect for deeper runs and riffles. It's especially effective in clear water when fished with a slow, steady retrieve to mimic a wounded baitfish.

Fishing Tactics

Dry Fly and Dry-Dropper Fishing

Dry fly and dry-dropper rigs are highly effective, especially during the late summer and early fall when terrestrial insects like grasshoppers, beetles, and ants are abundant.

• Dry-Dropper Rigs: This setup is ideal for the meadow sections of the Middle Fork. A buoyant dry fly (such as a Chubby Chernobyl, Amy’s Ant, or Foam Beetle) serves as an indicator fly, with a nymph or emerger (like a RS2 or Pheasant Tail Nymph) suspended below. This rig allows you to cover both surface-feeding trout and those holding just below the surface. The dry fly can entice aggressive strikes from fish looking for terrestrial insects, while the dropper targets trout feeding subsurface​

• Focus on Presentation: With clear water conditions, a drag-free drift is essential. Use longer leaders (9-12 feet) and fine tippets (5x-6x) to avoid spooking fish. Cast upstream and mend your line frequently to maintain a natural presentation. Target areas where the current slows near the banks or in seams, as these are prime spots for trout rising to dry flies.

Nymphing Techniques

Nymphing is a reliable tactic on the Middle Fork, especially in deeper runs, riffles, and pools where trout are feeding below the surface.

• Two-Fly Nymph Rig: Use a two-fly nymph rig to cover different depths and food sources. Start with a heavier attractor pattern, like a Copper John or BH Hare’s Ear Nymph, as your point fly, and add a smaller, more natural nymph like a Zebra Midge, RS2, or Pheasant Tail as a dropper. This combination allows you to target both bottom-feeding and mid-column trout​

• Adjust for Depth and Current: Vary the weight of your nymph rig to match the current speed and depth. In faster water, use more weight to get your flies down quickly to the strike zone. Strike indicators are useful for detecting subtle takes in the deeper, faster sections of the river.

• High-Sticking Technique: In tighter sections with faster currents, high-sticking (keeping a tight line with minimal slack) is effective for targeting trout in deeper runs and pocket water. This method gives you better control over the nymphs and increases sensitivity to strikes, especially when trout are holding close to the bottom.

Streamer Fishing

Streamer fishing can be very effective on the Middle Fork, particularly for targeting larger, more aggressive trout or when the water is slightly off-color due to recent rain.

• Swinging and Stripping Streamers: Use streamers like Woolly Buggers, Duracell, or Zonkers to imitate small baitfish, leeches, or crayfish. Cast these flies into deeper pools, along the edges of faster currents, or near undercut banks where larger trout may be hiding. Experiment with different retrieval speeds—short, quick strips can mimic a fleeing baitfish, while slower, steady pulls can imitate a wounded prey item​

• Focus on Low-Light Conditions: Streamer fishing is often most productive during low-light conditions, such as early morning or late evening. It can also be effective during overcast days or when the water is slightly off-color, making trout less cautious and more likely to chase larger prey.

Sight Fishing and Stealth Tactics

The Middle Fork’s clear waters often call for a stealthy approach, especially when sight fishing for trout holding in shallow runs or near the banks.

• Polarized Sunglasses: Use polarized sunglasses to reduce glare and help spot fish holding in deeper pools or along the river's edges. Seeing the fish allows for targeted casting and more precise presentations, increasing the likelihood of success.

• Long Leaders and Light Tippet: Use long leaders (9-12 feet) and light tippet (5x-6x) to reduce visibility and avoid spooking fish. Approach the water carefully, keep a low profile, and minimize unnecessary movements that could alert the trout to your presence.

• Read the Water: Look for subtle signs of fish activity, such as bubbles, surface disturbances, or slight changes in water color that indicate seams or feeding lanes. Focus on fishing these areas thoroughly before moving on.

Adapting to Changing Conditions

The Middle Fork can experience rapid changes in conditions due to weather or water releases. Adapting your tactics based on current conditions is key to success.

• Stay Flexible: Be prepared to switch daily tactics based on fish behavior and water conditions. If dry flies aren’t working, switch to nymphing or streamers. Keep a variety of flies and adjust your presentation as needed.

• Timing Your Outing: Early mornings and late afternoons are often the best times to fish the Middle Fork, as trout are more active and feeding. During the middle of the day, especially on hot, sunny days, focus on deeper pools or shaded areas where fish might be holding.

Access Points

Tomahawk State Wildlife Area

• Location: Near the town of Fairplay, CO, along County Road 9 (Hwy 9)
• Description: The Tomahawk State Wildlife Area offers nearly two miles of public access to the Middle Fork of the South Platte. This area features slower, wider sections of the river, perfect for beginner anglers or those looking to fish in a more relaxed setting. The terrain includes open meadows and a mix of riffles and deeper pools, ideal for dry fly fishing and nymphing.
• Access Tips: There are designated parking areas along County Road 9. Follow the signs to the wildlife area. Be sure to follow all posted rules and regulations regarding fishing and public use, as this area is managed by Colorado Parks and Wildlife​(

Badger Basin State Wildlife Area

• Location: Off of County Road 77 (Tarryall Road), near Hartsel, CO
• Description: This public access area provides several miles of fishable water along the Middle Fork. Badger Basin is a great spot for those looking for a more remote experience with less fishing pressure. The river here is narrower, with more riffles and pools, making it ideal for both dry fly fishing and nymphing.
• Access Tips: Parking is available in designated spots along County Road 77. Be prepared for a short walk to the river. Ensure you have the appropriate permits, and be aware of any specific fishing regulations or catch-and-release rules that apply to this area​(

Hartsel Springs Ranch

• Location: Near the town of Hartsel, CO, accessible from US Highway 24
• Description: Hartsel Springs Ranch offers both public and private access to the Middle Fork. This section is known for its trophy-sized rainbow trout and provides tailwater and freestone fishing opportunities. The ranch offers a mix of deeper pools, fast runs, and slower meadow sections, making it suitable for various fly fishing techniques.
• Access Tips: While some sections are open to the public, private areas also require permission or a fee to fish. It's best to check with local guides or the ranch management for specific access details. This area can be very productive, especially during hatches and low-light conditions​(

Spinney Mountain State Park

• Location: Located downstream of Spinney Mountain Reservoir, near Hartsel, CO
• Description: Although Spinney Mountain State Park is better known for its reservoir fishing, the tailwater section of the Middle Fork that flows out of the reservoir provides excellent fishing opportunities. This area is characterized by deeper runs and riffles, with cold, clear water supporting a healthy trout population, including rainbows, browns, and cutthroats.
• Access Tips: Park at designated parking areas near the dam or along the access road leading into the park. Be prepared for a short hike to reach the best fishing spots downstream from the reservoir. Make sure to have a valid state park pass or day-use permit​

Eleven Mile Reservoir Area

• Location: Near Lake George, CO, accessible via County Road 92
• Description: The Eleven Mile Reservoir area offers access to the Middle Fork below the reservoir dam. This stretch of the river is known for its big fish, including cutbows and browns. The river below the dam is a tailwater fishery, which maintains consistent water temperatures and flow, creating excellent conditions for trout fishing year-round.
• Access Tips: Enter through the main gate of Eleven Mile State Park and follow the signs to the tailwater section. The area can get crowded, especially during peak seasons, so arriving early is best to secure a good spot. Always check the local fishing regulations and carry the appropriate permits​